
Criminal Record Defense | Miami
Has an Old Sealed Record Come Up in Your New Florida Case?
Patrick Wilson Law, PLLC represents clients from Miami-Dade and Broward to the Florida Keys, and we can review how a prior record may affect the charge you face today.
By Patrick David Wilson · Published November 15, 2026
If you have a sealed case and now face a new charge, you may wonder whether the old record can be used against you. In short, a sealed record is hidden from public view, but it still exists, and a court can reach it in some situations. This page explains how Florida law handles that.
Short Answer: Can a Sealed Record Be Used in a New Criminal Case?
Sealing and expunction are separate legal remedies, and each has its own requirements under Florida law. Many people assume a sealed case disappears. It doesn’t. Information about a sealed record is confidential and exempt from public records law under § 943.059. The clerk must also certify the sealing order to the state attorney and the arresting agency. Under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.692, the sealed court file stays in a nonpublic index, subject to further order of the court.
Whether an old case matters in a new one depends on the facts of both cases. The outcome of the earlier case and the details of the new charge both count.
Patrick Wilson Law, PLLC is a Miami criminal defense firm. It focuses on criminal defense, including sealing and expunction, for clients in Miami-Dade and Broward counties and across South Florida. Patrick David Wilson is the responsible lawyer for this page, which offers general information.
If a new charge has you worried that an old sealed case will be pulled into it, we can review both files with you and talk through what comes next. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Sealing vs. Expunction Under Florida Law
Sealing hides a record from the public, while expunction removes it from most files. A common mistake is treating the two as the same thing. Sealing is governed by § 943.059, and expunction is governed by § 943.0585.
With a seal, the record still exists behind confidentiality rules. With expunction, any criminal justice agency holding the record must physically destroy or obliterate it. The Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) is the exception. It keeps the expunged record in all cases, as a confidential record.
Expunction has a gate.
Both routes need a court order and a Certificate of Eligibility from FDLE.
That is why the difference matters in a new case. A sealed record still exists, so it can be reached. An expunged record is destroyed, so less remains to be reached, though FDLE keeps its copy.
Who Can Still See a Sealed Record in Florida
Courts and criminal justice agencies can still see a sealed record. After a sealing order, the clerk certifies copies to the state attorney and the arresting agency. The clerk also certifies copies to any other agency the court records show received the record. Under § 943.059, FDLE must forward the order to the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Licensing and employment entities can also get access. The statute lets FDLE disclose a sealed record to listed entities for licensing, access authorization, and employment purposes. Fla. Stat. § 943.059 reads: “An employee of an entity set forth in subparagraph (b)1., subparagraph (b)4., subparagraph (b)5., subparagraph (b)6., subparagraph (b)8., subparagraph (b)9., subparagraph (b)10., or subparagraph (b)11. may not disclose information relating to the existence of a sealed criminal history record of a person seeking employment, access authorization, or licensure with such entity or contractor, except to the person to whom the criminal history record relates or to persons having direct responsibility for employment, access authorization, or licensure decisions.” Employees of those entities may not reveal that a sealed record exists, except to the person or to decision-makers.
For licensed professionals, the key question is whether the licensing body falls within that list. Who sees the record depends on the agency and its legal role.
The general public is different. The record is exempt from public records law, so a member of the public cannot get it through a public records request.
When a Sealed Record Can Come Up in a New Case
A sealed record can come up when a judge, prosecutor, or sentencing court has a legal reason to look at prior history. Here are the main paths.
Sentencing is the most concrete one. The state attorney prepares the Criminal Punishment Code scoresheet, and defense counsel reviews it for accuracy in all cases unless the judge directs otherwise, under § 921.0024. A prior serious felony can add 30 points, but only when the primary offense or an additional offense is ranked level 8, 9, or 10, and the prior serious felony is itself ranked level 8, 9, or 10 and the offender was serving a sentence for it or was released from it within 3 years before the new offense.
Withheld adjudication is another. For sealing and expunction eligibility, a withheld adjudication still counts as a conviction, under § 943.0584. Some offenses can never be sealed or expunged if the record is a conviction, including any offense in chapter 794 and felony battery.
Timing is the last one. Under § 775.15, a capital felony, a life felony, or a felony that resulted in a death may be prosecuted at any time. An old case isn’t always out of reach.
Sealing Does Not Rewrite the Original Case
Sealing changes who can see a record. It does not change what happened in the original case. Florida also limits when a judge can withhold adjudication. Under § 775.08435, a court may not withhold adjudication for any capital, life, or first-degree felony. It also limits withholding for certain third-degree domestic violence felonies, unless the state attorney requests it in writing or the court makes written findings.
Non-citizens face separate federal rules. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1227, a non-citizen who is convicted, at any time after admission, of a crime of domestic violence, stalking, or child abuse, child neglect, or child abandonment is deportable, although the Attorney General may waive the application of that deportability ground for crimes of domestic violence and crimes of stalking for a non-citizen who has been battered or subjected to extreme cruelty and who is not and was not the primary perpetrator of violence in the relationship. Federal immigration law applies its own rules. A non-citizen should have that analysis done before any filing decision.
Licensed professionals should weigh the licensing point above before any filing, too.
How Sealing Works and How Many Records Can Be Sealed
Sealing requires a written petition, a Certificate of Eligibility, and a court order. FDLE issues the certificate, and its sealing and expunging process explains the requirement. In general, the steps look like this:
- Get a Certificate of Eligibility from FDLE.
- File a written petition with the clerk, with a sworn statement that you meet the eligibility rule and have no other petition pending.
- Serve the prosecutor and the arresting authority, who may respond.
- The court may receive evidence and may deny the petition at its sole discretion.
- If relief is granted, the clerk sends certified copies of the order to the agencies named.
The petitioner pays for certified copies unless indigent, under Rule 3.692. A common mistake is filing before the certificate is in hand, because the court may not order a criminal justice agency to expunge or seal a record until the petitioner has applied for and received the certificate.
On how many records, a petition covers one arrest or one incident. The court may add related arrests only when they directly relate to the original arrest and the order says so, under § 943.059.
A prior sealing also affects expunction. If an earlier sealing rested on a withheld adjudication or on charges not dismissed before trial, expunction generally requires 10 years of sealing first, under § 943.0585. Fla. Stat. § 943.0585 reads: “The requirement for the record to have previously been sealed for a minimum of 10 years does not apply if a plea was not entered or all charges related to the arrest or alleged criminal activity to which the petition to expunge pertains were dismissed before trial or a judgment of acquittal was rendered by a judge or a verdict of not guilty was rendered by a judge or jury.” That requirement does not apply if no plea was entered, all charges were dismissed before trial, or there was an acquittal or not-guilty verdict.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

Facing a New Charge With an Old Sealed Record
If you face a new charge and have an old sealed case, the answer turns on both files. Your license, your immigration status, and your prior sentence can all change how the old case matters. Pull together the sealing order, any certificate of eligibility, and the case numbers for both matters. Having them in hand makes the first conversation more useful.
Can a sealed record be used in a new case in Florida?
Yes, in some situations. Sealing keeps the record confidential, but it does not erase it from every file.
Is a sealed record the same as an expunged record?
No. A sealed record still exists, while an expunged record is physically destroyed, except that FDLE keeps its copy.
Does a withheld adjudication count as a conviction in Florida?
If a new charge has you worried that an old sealed case will be pulled into it, we can review both files with you. The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. Call 786-761-1719 or send us a message through our contact page.
How Patrick Wilson Law Approaches Sealed Records
We Pull the Full Record
We review the sealed matter, the new charge and every related file so you know exactly what a court, prosecutor or agency may be able to see.
We Protect Your Confidentiality
Information you share with us is handled in confidence, and we explain who may have access to older records before you decide how to proceed.
We Plan Around the Prior Record
Early planning can help shape how a sealed or expunged record is addressed in the new case, including what you say and what you sign.
Focus on Criminal Defense
Our practice focuses on criminal defense in South Florida, including first-time offender matters, DUI, domestic violence and licensed professional cases.
Important: Do Not Assume a Sealed Record Stays Hidden
Before you answer any question about your history, whether from police, a court, an employer or a licensing board, speak with a lawyer. A sealed record may still appear in some files, so an incomplete answer can create problems in the new case.
What to Bring to Your Consultation
Charging Papers
Bring any arrest report, notice to appear, bond paperwork or court documents from the new case.
Prior Record Details
Note the year, county and charge of each earlier matter, including whether it was sealed or expunged and the order that did so.
Licensing or Work Issues
If your job, license or immigration status is affected, bring any letters or notices you have received.
Your Questions
Write down what you are most worried about so we can address it during the free consultation.