
Vehicular Homicide Defense | Miami and South Florida
Fatal Crash Restitution in Florida Criminal Cases: What Miami Defendants Need to Know
Restitution can be part of a sentence after a fatal crash case. Patrick Wilson Law, PLLC focuses on criminal defense across South Florida and can explain how restitution may affect your case and your future.
By Patrick David Wilson · Published October 29, 2026
Short Answer: Restitution Can Be Ordered in a Florida Criminal Case
Yes, a Florida criminal court must order the defendant to pay restitution to the victim after a fatal crash. If the victim died, the victim’s estate is also a victim under Fla. Stat. § 775.089, and the victim’s next of kin are victims too if the death resulted from the offense. The rule is in Fla. Stat. § 775.089. It says the court “shall order” restitution “in addition to any punishment.” Restitution is part of the sentence, so it comes up at or after a plea or trial, not at arrest. It is a sentencing order, not a civil verdict on fault.
If a fatal crash has led to a charge or investigation and you're unsure what restitution could mean for your family, we offer a free, confidential first consultation. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.

How the Court Sets Restitution in a Fatal Crash Case
Restitution covers losses the offense caused, directly or indirectly. When bodily injury leads to death, the court can order payment equal to the cost of necessary funeral and related services. The victim can also recover income lost because of the offense. The statute defines “victim” to include the estate and next of kin of a person who died.
The state attorney must prove the amount of the loss. Families usually work through the prosecutor to document bills, receipts and lost pay. If the sides disagree on the amount, the judge decides by a preponderance of the evidence, which means more likely than not. The judge can consider hearsay if it has minimal indicia of reliability.
For a crash that involves death, the rule is firmer. Fla. Stat. § 316.027 says that when a driver unlawfully leaves the scene of a crash involving injury or death, the court “shall order” restitution for any damage or loss unless it finds clear and compelling reasons not to. At the sentencing hearing, the court must decide whether restitution applies. Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.720 also requires copies of the order to go to the defendant, the defense lawyer, the state attorney and the victim.
Restitution Versus a Civil Wrongful Death Claim
Restitution is a sentencing order from the criminal court. A wrongful death claim is a separate civil lawsuit. Florida law provides a right of action for civil damages under section 768.19 under all circumstances for all deaths described in the vehicular homicide statute. That statute says a right of action for civil damages exists under s. 768.19 for all deaths it describes, under all circumstances.
The two tracks answer different questions. The criminal court sets the sentence and the restitution amount for the losses the statute lists. A civil case is a different proceeding with different parties and procedures.
Many families hear “restitution” and assume it settles everything. It does not. Restitution does not bar a later civil claim, as the next section explains. Knowing that difference early helps families plan.
How the Criminal Case and a Civil Claim Can Overlap
A criminal conviction can matter in a later civil case. Under § 775.089, a conviction for the offense behind the restitution order stops the defendant from denying its essential allegations in a later civil case. In plain words, the defendant cannot deny the core facts again.
The overlap also works on money. The restitution amount is set off against any later independent civil recovery. Under Fla. Stat. § 775.089(8), an order of restitution does not bar a later civil remedy or recovery, but the amount of that restitution is set off against any subsequent independent civil recovery.
Plea agreements matter too. A restitution order entered as part of a plea agreement will not bar any later civil remedy or recovery, but its amount is set off against any later independent civil recovery. The agreement must say so.
Fault can change a civil result. Fla. Stat. § 768.81 says a party found more than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover damages, with medical negligence excepted. This rule can matter when the crash facts are disputed. This firm handles criminal defense, so a civil claim may need a separate lawyer.
Factors That Shape Whether and How Much Restitution Applies
The charge is the first factor. Under § 782.071, vehicular homicide is a second-degree felony. It becomes a first-degree felony if the person knew or should have known the accident occurred and failed to give information and render aid. A prior conviction of listed offenses also raises the degree.
Leaving the scene carries its own rules. Under § 316.027, a willful violation that causes death is a first-degree felony with a four-year mandatory minimum. The defendant may move to depart from that minimum, unless the violation was committed while driving under the influence.
Plea offers are a major decision point. Fla. R. Crim. P. 3.171 requires defense counsel to advise the client of all plea offers and the likely results of each. The client decides whether to accept.
Ability to pay also counts. Under § 948.06, once the state establishes a failure to pay restitution, a probationer who asserts inability to pay must prove by clear and convincing evidence that he does not have the present resources available to pay, despite sufficient bona fide efforts legally to acquire them. If the court finds he made sufficient good-faith efforts and still cannot pay, it must consider measures other than prison. Fla. Stat. § 948.06 reads: “Only if alternate measures are not adequate to meet the state’s interests in punishment and deterrence may the court imprison a probationer or offender in community control who has demonstrated sufficient bona fide efforts to pay restitution or the cost of supervision.” Whether restitution applies in your case depends on the facts.

If You or a Family Member Is Facing a Fatal Crash Charge
If a fatal crash has led to a charge or an investigation, the restitution question often comes up before the plea or sentencing decision. Talking it through early helps you see what is at stake.
Patrick Wilson Law, PLLC is a Miami criminal defense firm. Patrick David Wilson is the lawyer responsible for this page. If you are wondering what restitution could mean for you or your family, we offer a free, confidential first consultation with no obligation to continue. Call 786-761-1719 or send us a message.
Can restitution be ordered if there is no sentence?
No. Restitution is part of the sentence, so it is tied to a plea or trial result that leads to a sentence.
Does a restitution order decide a wrongful death lawsuit?
No. A restitution order does not bar a later civil claim, but the amount is set off against any civil recovery.
Can a restitution order become a lien on property?
Yes.
How Patrick Wilson Law Approaches These Cases
Criminal Defense Focus
Patrick Wilson Law, PLLC focuses on criminal defense, including vehicular homicide and traffic homicide charges in Miami-Dade and Broward County.
Defense Across the Sentencing Process
Restitution is decided within the criminal case. Our team looks at the plea, the sentence and the record together so you understand the full picture.
Clear Explanations
We explain how restitution, criminal penalties and any civil claims may connect, using plain language before you make decisions.
Confidential Consultation
Your first consultation is free, confidential and comes with no obligation to continue.
Important: Restitution Depends on Your Case
Every fatal crash case is different. No lawyer can promise how a court will handle restitution or what results your case will produce. Speak with a criminal defense attorney about your specific facts before you make any decisions.
Common Questions About Restitution After a Fatal Crash
Is restitution tied to a sentence?
Restitution is part of a criminal sentence, so it generally follows a plea or trial result that leads to sentencing.
How does it affect a civil case?
A restitution order can interact with a later wrongful death or civil claim. Its effect on any civil matter depends on the facts and should be reviewed with counsel.
What should I bring to a consultation?
Bring any charging documents, court notices, plea paperwork and a timeline of events, so we can review your situation accurately.
Can I leave a message instead?
If you prefer, you can leave us a message and our office will follow up to schedule your free, confidential consultation.